The French far-right has been citing a figure of 500,000 new foreigners entering France every year, but experts say this number is inaccurate. Jordan Bardella, president of the National Rally, recently stated that 5 million foreigners have entered France in the past 10 years, calculated by adding the number of legal residence permits, students, asylum seekers, and unaccompanied minors. However, experts argue that this calculation is flawed.

François Héran, a professor emeritus at the Collège de France specializing in migration, points out that Bardella's calculation commits a "classic error" by not accounting for the fact that the total number of residence permits issued in a given year includes valid requests made in previous months or years. This results in double or triple counting of certain categories of foreigners.

Tania Racho, a doctor of European law and judge-assessor at the National Court of Asylum Law, also disputes Bardella's figure, calling it "totally false." She argues that it represents a double count of certain categories of foreigners, despite the availability of official statistics. Official numbers from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the French National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE) also contradict Bardella's claim.

According to the OECD, 333,700 permanent immigrants arrived in France in 2025, while INSEE estimates that 313,000 foreigners, regardless of their administrative status, entered France in 2024. However, experts stress that these numbers should not be added up over several years, and that deaths and departures must be taken into account to get an accurate picture.

INSEE provides an example of the period 2006-2022, which saw an average of 272,000 foreigners arriving in France each year, but also an average of 90,000 departures and 56,000 deaths per year among this immigrant population. The institute notes that for every 10 immigrants who arrive in France in a given year, there are approximately 3 departures and 2 deaths.

Experts warn that simply adding up the numbers of foreigners arriving in France over several years creates a distorted view of reality. AFP Factuel, a fact-checking service, notes that the latest data from INSEE on the migration balance, which dates back to 2022, shows an increase of 348,000 people among foreigners in France, but this figure includes a record number of Ukrainian refugees.

The dispute over the number of foreigners entering France highlights the challenges of accurately tracking migration trends. While the far-right continues to cite inflated numbers, experts stress the importance of relying on official statistics and taking into account factors such as deaths and departures to get a nuanced understanding of the issue.

Key points

  • Experts dispute the claim that 500,000 foreigners enter France annually, citing flawed calculations and inflated numbers.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.