Five Court of Appeal judges in Kenya have filed a defamation lawsuit against Captain Kung'u Muigai, a nephew of former President Jomo Kenyatta and cousin of former President Uhuru Kenyatta. The judges, Justices Milton Asike-Makhandia, Kathurima M'Inoti, Sankale Ole Kantai, Francis Tuiyott, and John Mativo, claim that Muigai made false and defamatory statements against them on social media. The statements alleged that the judges received a $2.5 million bribe to influence a 2024 ruling in a property dispute between a borrower and a bank.
The dispute centers on a Sh18.6 million loan advanced by Kenya Commercial Bank (KCB) to Benjoh Amalgamated Ltd in 1989. The loan was secured against three properties, and the bank moved to sell the properties after the borrower defaulted. The case has been litigated for over three decades, with the Court of Appeal delivering a ruling on May 24, 2024, that dismissed Benjoh's attempt to reopen an earlier decision upholding a consent order. Muigai claims that the ruling was procured through a bribe and has lodged a complaint with the Judicial Service Commission (JSC).
Muigai argues that his statements were justified and that he was reporting concerns raised with the JSC. He maintains that the allegations against the judges should be investigated by the JSC, rather than a defamation court. The judges' advocate, Peter Wanyama, has described the allegations as "entirely unfounded and completely preposterous." The judges are seeking damages, an apology, and an order barring further publication of the defamatory statements.
The case filed on August 6, 2026, claims that Muigai made the contested statements in media briefings on September 8 and 10, 2025. The statements were published on various social media platforms, including Facebook, X, LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. The judges' lawyer, Peter Wanyama, says that the publications damaged the judges' reputations and seeks a declaration of defamation, an unqualified public apology, and deletion of the material.
Muigai's defense, filed on September 10, 2026, denies that the comments were false, malicious, or defamatory. His advocate, Nelson Havi, argues that the case is an abuse of court process and that the JSC should examine Muigai's complaint about the judges' conduct. Havi claims that the JSC has not rendered a decision on Muigai's complaint and that the judges are attempting to cover up the alleged bribery.
The dispute over the consent order dates back to 1992, when the parties recorded a consent before Justice Erastus Githinji. The consent allowed KCB to realise the securities, but the companies later challenged its validity. In 2018, Benjoh applied to reopen the Court of Appeal's 2017 decision upholding the consent, but the five judges dismissed the application in May 2024.
The judges' lawsuit against Muigai is ongoing, with the parties expected to present their cases in court. The outcome of the case will have significant implications for the Kenyan judiciary and the protection of judges' reputations.
Key points
- The five Court of Appeal judges have sued Captain Kung'u Muigai over defamation claims related to a 2024 ruling in a property dispute.
- Muigai claims that the ruling was procured through a bribe and has lodged a complaint with the Judicial Service Commission (JSC).
- The judges are seeking damages, an apology, and an order barring further publication of the defamatory statements.
Reporting sources
- Inside five judges’ defamation suit against Kenyatta kin · https://rwandatoday.africa/