The European Union's approach to diplomacy with Iran has undergone a significant transformation over the past decade. In 2016, the European Parliament adopted a report on relations with Iran, led by British MEP Richard Howitt, which proposed a strategy for dialogue with Tehran following the conclusion of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). The report was adopted with a significant majority of 456 votes against 174, with 67 abstentions. This marked a moment where Europe seemed capable of acting with a strategic vision.

The report proposed developing relations in key areas, including political dialogue, trade, academic exchanges, human rights, and regional security. It offered European expertise to help Iran meet the criteria of the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), a crucial step towards economic reform. The report also recognized Iran as an indispensable actor in resolving conflicts in Syria, Iraq, and Yemen. It called for European diplomacy to encourage rapprochement between Tehran and Riyadh, a call that was later heeded by China.

The reactions to the report were revealing. The National Iranian American Council (NIAC), a pro-diplomacy group based in Washington, welcomed the report with enthusiasm. However, groups such as the AJC Transatlantic Institute (TAI) denounced the report, criticizing it for not sufficiently highlighting Iran's threats to Israel and its human rights record. The report's critics presented a false dilemma: defending human rights or engaging in dialogue with Tehran.

Despite these criticisms, the report was not simply an exercise in parliamentary rhetoric. In the weeks following its adoption, the EU's Foreign Affairs Council endorsed the parliamentary approach to dialogue with Tehran. The council also supported the establishment of an EU delegation in Tehran. This marked a situation where parliamentary diplomacy had contributed to shaping the EU's overall political position.

The Iranian government's response to the report was also instructive. The spokesperson for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs acknowledged that the document contained promising points that could help open new horizons and develop EU-Iran relations. However, there were also opponents within Iran, such as Mohammad Javad Larijani, who opposed the opening of an EU delegation in Tehran, citing concerns about interference in Iran's internal affairs.

Over the past decade, Europe's relations with Iran have deteriorated significantly. The continent has lost much of its economic weight, and its diplomatic influence has regressed considerably. Europe's role in managing regional security crises has become marginal. The shift in European diplomacy has been driven in part by the US's increasingly hardline stance on Iran.

Today, Europe largely follows US policy on Iran, which has led to a decline in diplomatic engagement and a more confrontational approach. The consequences of this shift are far-reaching, with implications for regional security, economic cooperation, and human rights. As Europe continues to navigate its relations with Iran, it must consider the lessons of the past decade and the importance of a strategic and pragmatic approach to diplomacy.

Key points

  • The European Parliament's 2016 report on relations with Iran proposed a strategy for dialogue with Tehran, which was later endorsed by the EU's Foreign Affairs Council.
  • The report recognized Iran as an indispensable actor in resolving conflicts in Syria, Iraq, and Yemen.
  • Europe's relations with Iran have deteriorated significantly over the past decade, with the continent largely following US policy.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.