A woman from the Eastern Cape has won her legal battle against the Minister of Police, with the Mthatha High Court ordering R124,000 in damages. The court ruled that the police had unlawfully entered and searched her home, and seized her livestock and other belongings, during a raid in May 2020. The woman had claimed R4m in damages for impairment of dignity and deprivation of freedom, among other things.

The raid was carried out by armed police officers at the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, and followed a dispute over the property of the woman's deceased partner. A court order had been granted, directing the woman to hand over certain property to another woman, but the order did not authorise the police to enter and search her home. Judge Lindiwe Rusi found that the police had acted unlawfully and awarded the woman R100,000 for the invasion of her home and R24,000 for the loss of eight pigs.

The woman had alleged that the police had seized 24 pigs valued at R6,250 each, R30,000 in cash, and a wheelchair, but the court found that she had not provided sufficient evidence to support her claims. Rusi accepted that 24 pigs had been removed from the woman's premises, but found that she had not proved ownership of 16 of the pigs, which were identified in the court order as property claimed by the deceased's family. However, the woman had established patrimonial loss in respect of the remaining eight pigs.

The court also found that the police had failed to establish facts justifying their entry, search, and seizure of the woman's property. Rusi said that the conduct of the police demonstrated abuse of their authority and that the woman's home had been unlawfully invaded and left in a chaotic state. The judge acknowledged that the woman's children had been present during the search and had been exposed to intimidating police conduct.

The woman's identity was withheld in the judgment, but Rusi said that the right to privacy, linked to a person's dignity and integrity, enjoys constitutional protection, and that these rights had been violated without justification. The judge considered R100,000 to be an appropriate award for the woman's general damages, and also awarded her R24,000 for the loss of the eight pigs.

The police had argued that they had acted under a high court order relating to a burial dispute, but Rusi found that the order had been granted in unrelated proceedings and did not authorise the police operation. The woman had taken the Minister of Police to court, claiming damages for the unlawful raid, and the court ultimately ruled in her favour.

The award of R124,000 in damages brings an end to the woman's six-year legal battle against the Minister of Police. The case highlights the importance of protecting citizens' constitutional rights to privacy and dignity, and the need for law enforcement agencies to act lawfully and with respect for the rights of individuals.

Key points

  • The Mthatha High Court awarded a woman R124,000 in damages for an unlawful police raid on her home in 2020.
  • The police had seized eight pigs and other property, but the court found that they had acted unlawfully and without justification.
  • The case highlights the importance of protecting citizens' constitutional rights to privacy and dignity.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.