A tense exchange occurred at the Botswana Court of Appeal as lawyers for Khulaco Proprietary Limited, linked to businessman Bakang Seretse, failed to submit required heads of argument. Instead of filing the arguments, they sent a letter raising procedural objections and requesting additional material, including the official record of earlier proceedings. The court had directed them to submit the arguments to address specific questions.
The Court of Appeal had set out three questions for argument, including whether exceptional circumstances must exist for the court to reconsider one of its decisions, whether Khulaco's founding papers adequately pleaded such circumstances, and whether supporting affidavits contained facts to establish them. Khulaco's lawyer, Samuel Plaatjie, asked for an opportunity to obtain the record and supplement their papers before proceeding to argument.
The court bench was unconvinced by Plaatjie's request. Justice Bess Nkabinde reminded him that counsel's duty is to assist the court with substantive submissions on identified issues. She also noted that the hearing could not be deferred without a formal application for postponement. Presiding Justice Goemekgabo Tebogo-Maruping expressed the court's displeasure, stressing that correspondence was no substitute for heads of argument.
The case, CACGB-105-25, involves an application by Khulaco and another party against the Attorney General and four other respondents, seeking reconsideration of a final judgment previously delivered by the Court of Appeal. Lawyers for the Attorney General, Tshiamo Rantao and Mboki Chilisa, were permitted to proceed with their submissions after complying with the court's directive.
Khulaco's lawyers contended that it would be procedurally unfair to require answers before receiving the complete record, which included certified appeal documents, audio recordings, and judicial notes. They sought this material to address concerns about the treatment of factual disputes in the original proceedings.
The applicants also questioned the composition of the panel, noting that Court of Appeal President Justice Tebogo Tau was named as a respondent and sat on the panel that delivered the judgment now under challenge. They queried whether the Judge President's power to constitute appeal panels should be exercised in a case involving her own earlier decision, citing concerns about the appearance of judicial impartiality.
The court's criticism of Khulaco's lawyers reflects the importance of adhering to procedural rules and court directives. The case will continue with the Attorney General's submissions, and the court will determine whether exceptional circumstances exist to reconsider its previous decision. The outcome will have implications for the applicants and the court's jurisdiction.
Key points
- The Court of Appeal rebuked Khulaco's lawyers for failing to file required heads of argument, despite being directed to do so.
- The case involves an application to reconsider a final judgment previously delivered by the Court of Appeal.
- The court's decision will have implications for the applicants and its jurisdiction to reconsider previous decisions.
Reporting sources
- Court of Appeal rebukes Seretse’s lawyers over missing arguments · weekendpost.co.bw