Every December, thousands of boys in Tanzania disappear into church compounds for a week-long circumcision program. The modern rite of passage, which was once performed by village elders, now involves a surgeon in medical scrubs and a hefty price tag. Depending on the church's status, location, and program duration, parents pay between Sh10,000 and Sh50,000 per child. This seasonal industry is worth tens of millions of shillings annually.

The trend is a departure from traditional circumcision practices, where village elders played a significant role. According to Joseph Kaguthi, convener of elders and clergy in the joint Council of Elders in Mt Kenya, circumcision was a cultural practice that involved the community. A family would pay the elders with a goat, beer, or respect, and the boy would join an age-set that governed him for life. However, missionaries disrupted this order in the 1920s to 1950s.

Missionaries from the Church of Scotland (PCEA), the Catholic Church, and others banned traditional circumcision, citing safety concerns. They built hospitals, and doctors replaced traditional circumcisers. The hospital replaced the forest, and elders lost control. Later, the Mungiki sect and other gangs made home-based healing risky, and boys recuperating at home were recruited into gangs. This created an opportunity for churches to take over the practice.

Today, church-run circumcision programs have become a lucrative business. Kiama Kia Ma national patron Kung'u Muigai laments that "nobody calls it business, they call it ministry." Economically, it is a seasonal industry worth tens of millions every year. Some parents, like James Rono of Eldoret, pay Sh17,000 for a one-week camp at a Catholic church. The fee covers the doctor's charges, food, accommodation, and mentorship program.

Church leaders argue that the programs provide a safe and guided environment for boys to undergo circumcision. Bishop Joseph Kagunda of ACK Mt Kenya West, a pioneer of church-run circumcision, admits that the church charges a fee but argues that it provides additional services like counseling and guidance. An Eldoret bishop, who wishes to remain anonymous, says that most churches offering the services are not after profit but aim to provide a valuable service to the community.

However, there are concerns about the commercialization of circumcision. Bishop Wilson Kurui of Jesus Love Ministries in Eldoret cautions that the service should not be viewed as an opportunity to generate income but as a way for the church to support society. Some critics, like PCEA's Rev Hezekiah Murage, question whether the camps produce real manhood or just a certificate. Theologian Dr. Samuel Ndogo counters that criticism must be based on evidence, not anecdotes.

The dominance of churches in circumcision has sparked debate among elders, who feel that their cultural practices are being eroded. Thomas Ingara, a 91-year-old Tiriki traditional circumciser, argues that churches are forcing foreign culture into their rites while collecting huge sums of money from poor parents. Kiama Kia Ma proposes a compromise, where the church teaches boys for one week and elders for another week. However, some churches have refused, citing concerns about elders teaching "pagan things."

Key points

  • Churches in Tanzania have turned circumcision into a lucrative business, with parents paying up to Sh50,000 per child for the service.
  • The trend has sparked debate among elders, who feel that their cultural practices are being eroded.
  • Safety concerns and the commercialization of circumcision have raised questions about the church's role in the practice.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.