President Duma Boko's announcement to return 52,000 square kilometres of ancestral land in the Central Kalahari Game Reserve (CKGR) to indigenous communities has sparked both applause and debate. The proposed restitution, described as the largest structured restitution of land rights to an indigenous population within a protected area on the African continent, has been welcomed by advocates of indigenous rights. The San people, who have historically faced displacement from their ancestral territories, are expected to benefit from the plan.
The Regional Chairperson of the Indigenous Peoples of Africa Coordinating Committee, Khoebee Satau, has described the government's commitment as a significant shift from historical dispossession towards restorative justice. Satau said the decision represents an important opportunity to acknowledge the rights, identity and cultural heritage of the San, particularly the G||ana and G|ui communities. He noted that for decades, the San have struggled to preserve their cultural identity against policies of forced assimilation.
Satau explained that land holds deeper significance for the San beyond its economic value, describing it as an archive of their history and the foundation of their spirituality. However, Satau stressed that the success of the proposed restitution would depend on how the government implements the commitment. He called for meaningful access to ancestral land, and protection against external interests, particularly mining and tourism operations that could undermine indigenous communities' rights.
Job Morris, Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities Advocacy and Communications Officer at Community Leaders Network, said the announcement is one of the most significant developments in Botswana's contemporary human rights and land governance discourse. Morris said it represents an important political commitment to addressing historical injustices that have affected the San people and other Indigenous communities for generations.
However, renowned conservationist and Professor at the Okavango Research Institute in Maun, Joseph Mbaiwa, has cautioned the government against the proposed return, arguing that it could create complex land ownership and conservation challenges. Mbaiwa said while he supports community rights, he does not support them blindly, warning that the decision could open what he described as a Pandora's Box of competing ancestral land claims.
Mbaiwa further argued that other communities, including the Batawana and Bayei, could also advance claims over Moremi Game Reserve, while communities previously residing in Chobe National Park could seek similar recognition. Kebareeditse Ntshogotho, a fellow Mosarwa from Khwai, also supported Professor Mbaiwa's position, saying the Khwai community would formally inform the President of their intention to return to their ancestral land in Moremi Game Reserve.
The government's plan to return ancestral land to indigenous communities has raised concerns about its implementation, with some conservationists warning that it could create competing land claims by other communities that were also displaced from protected areas. The success of the proposed restitution will depend on how the government balances the rights of indigenous communities with conservation and commercial interests.
Key points
- The proposed restitution of 52,000 square kilometres of land in the Central Kalahari Game Reserve to indigenous communities has sparked both applause and debate.
- The plan has raised concerns about its implementation, with some conservationists warning that it could create competing land claims by other communities.
- The success of the proposed restitution will depend on how the government balances the rights of indigenous communities with conservation and commercial interests.
Reporting sources
- Many ancestral land claims looming Boko warned against his CKGR plan · The Patriot on Sunday