Avinash Ramkistan, a 40-year-old man from Glen Ashley, Durban, has been denied an urgent bail bid while pursuing an appeal of his conviction and 20-year prison sentence. Ramkistan was convicted of threatening an acting high court judge, prosecutors, and police officers through emails, voice recordings, and Facebook posts. His application for bail was struck off the roll by the Durban High Court, which found that it did not meet the requirements of urgency and that he had not exhausted other available avenues.
Ramkistan was arrested in March 2024 and charged with several counts of intimidation, crimen injuria, and contraventions of the National Prosecuting Authority Act and the Cybercrimes Act 19 of 2020. During the trial, one of the State witnesses, an acting high court judge, testified that she was left feeling insulted, embarrassed, and fearful after Ramkistan accused her of being “fake” and made threats to incite violence. Ramkistan represented himself during the trial and pleaded not guilty. The Durban Regional Court found him guilty on all counts in May, and he was sentenced to an effective 20 years' imprisonment on July 20.
The sentence included 10 years for 11 counts of intimidation, five years for four counts of crimen injuria, eight years for four counts of contravening the Cybercrimes Act, and three years for contravening the NPA Act, with some sentences ordered to run concurrently. Ramkistan applied for leave to appeal his conviction and sentence on July 22, but the trial court refused his application on September 2, citing no reasonable prospects of success. He then pursued a petition procedure under Section 309C of the Criminal Procedure Act.
In his bail application's founding affidavit, Ramkistan cited the Supreme Court of Appeal's recognition of a common-law power to release a would-be appellant on bail pending a petition. However, Senior State advocate Krishen Shah, opposing the application on behalf of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), argued that Ramkistan had not made out a case of urgency or found jurisdiction for the court to entertain the matter. The DPP's deputy, Noxolo Tokwana, stated that Ramkistan's continued detention remained lawful following the refusal of his application for leave to appeal.
Tokwana also noted that Ramkistan had not lodged the appeal record and petition with the registrar of the high court, and therefore, there was technically no petition pending in the high court. She added that Ramkistan's failure to seek leave to appeal pending the petition before the lower court was not without consequence. The DPP was not unsympathetic to Ramkistan's situation, given the constitutional protection of the right to liberty, but his detention was judicially sanctioned.
Ramkistan's situation highlights the complexities of the appellate process and the requirements for bail pending appeal. His case demonstrates that the courts will carefully consider the merits of an application and the applicable laws before granting bail. The outcome of Ramkistan's appeal and petition remains uncertain, and his continued detention will likely be re-evaluated in the context of his ongoing legal proceedings.
The case also raises questions about the balance between the right to liberty and the need to protect the public and the justice system from threats and intimidation. Ramkistan's actions were deemed serious enough to warrant a 20-year sentence, and his attempts to appeal and seek bail will be closely scrutinized by the courts. The final outcome of his case will depend on the application of the law and the evaluation of the evidence presented.
Key points
- Ramkistan's urgent bail bid was denied due to lack of urgency and failure to exhaust available avenues.
- The 40-year-old man was sentenced to 20 years in prison for threatening a high court judge, prosecutors, and police officers.
- Ramkistan's appeal and petition are ongoing, with the courts carefully considering his case and the applicable laws.