Algerian diplomat Amar Belani has expressed concerns over the European Union's intentions in its association agreement with Algeria. In a recent statement, Belani questioned whether the EU genuinely seeks to build a partnership with its southern neighbors or merely aims to manage the region's politics, economy, and security. He criticized the EU's approach as hypocritical, paternalistic, and self-serving.

Belani, who was part of the negotiation team, highlighted the unequal context in which the agreement was signed. The negotiations took place in 2002, when Algeria was still reeling from a dark decade and was isolated internationally. He praised the efforts of the chief negotiator, Ambassador Halim Benattallah, but noted that the EU took advantage of Algeria's vulnerable position to secure favorable terms.

The diplomat revealed that the Algerian government had initially prioritized joining the World Trade Organization (WTO) over negotiating with the EU. However, former President Bouteflika decided to focus on the EU agreement, which Belani believes was a strategic move to improve relations with Europe and escape international isolation. This decision has led to the current situation, where the EU enjoys favorable trade terms while hindering Algeria's WTO accession.

Belani argued that the EU's policy towards its southern neighbors is driven by self-interest. The European Union's Neighborhood Policy, launched in 2004, offered limited market access, investments, and financial aid in exchange for political, economic, and institutional reforms. However, Belani claimed that this approach is inherently unequal, with the EU imposing its rules and conditions without regard for national specificities or economic disparities.

Despite revisions to the EU's neighborhood policy, Belani believes that the fundamental approach remains unchanged. The EU prioritizes stability, security, and migration control over democratic principles and partnership. He cited the 2015 revision, which emphasized security concerns, and the 2021 New Agenda for the Mediterranean, which continues to focus on risk management rather than shared prosperity.

Belani described the EU's partnership approach as paternalistic, selective, and self-serving. He argued that the EU dictates the terms of engagement, prioritizing its own strategic interests over those of its partners. This approach has led to a lack of trust and skepticism among Algeria and other southern neighbors, who feel that the EU is not genuinely invested in their development or prosperity.

The diplomat concluded by questioning the EU's true intentions, suggesting that it may be more interested in managing the region's risks and threats than in building a genuine partnership. As the EU faces growing demands from its southern neighbors, Belani's comments highlight the need for a more equitable and mutually beneficial approach to their relationship.

Key points

  • The EU's association agreement with Algeria has been criticized for being unequal and self-serving.
  • Algerian diplomat Amar Belani questions the EU's intentions in its association agreement with Algeria.
  • The EU's neighborhood policy prioritizes stability, security, and migration control over democratic principles and partnership.

Reporting sources

Share this story

Written by

SaharaWire Newsroom
SaharaWire

Reporting for SaharaWire from the Nairobi bureau.