The African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights, based in Arusha, Tanzania, will deliver an advisory opinion in 2027 on the obligations of states regarding climate change. The court, comprising 11 judges, has jurisdiction to interpret and apply the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights. In May 2025, the Pan-African Union of Lawyers and dozens of NGOs and lawyers from the continent, led by Liberian lawyer Alfred Brownell, requested the court's opinion on states' obligations to address the climate crisis.
The request comes after three international courts have established climate action as a legal obligation of states. In May 2024, the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea and in July 2025, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights issued strong opinions on climate obligations. Most recently, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) concluded that existing international law imposes obligations on states to protect the climate, potentially leading to reparations for affected countries.
The ICJ's opinion has raised hopes among climate defenders, but it has been criticized for being vague on reparations. Alfred Brownell, from the African Climate Platform, is seeking a clearer definition of states' responsibilities, translating human suffering, droughts, and infrastructure destruction into specific international responsibilities. He emphasizes that reparations go beyond financial compensation, potentially including technology transfers, in-kind assistance, and debt cancellations.
The African Court has received contributions from 117 organizations and states, with many developing legal arguments on reparations. The issue of colonialism is also being raised, with some arguing that former colonial powers bear greater responsibility for addressing the consequences of historical injustices. Nikki Reisch, director of climate at the environmental lawyers' organization CIEL, notes that recognizing the historical roots of climate injustice in colonialism strengthens the case for reparations.
Researchers have estimated that the climate debt owed to sub-Saharan Africa could reach $45 trillion by 2050. While a lawsuit against a Western country is unlikely today, it may become more plausible in the future. Melanie Murcott, a researcher at the University of Cape Town, believes that these advisory opinions are laying the groundwork for future cases and may have a ripple effect in various types of disputes.
Alfred Brownell has requested that the African Court hold public hearings in each region of the continent, given the high stakes. The court is considering this request, and a spokesperson has promised to announce any decision in time for public participation. Many hope that the judges will deliver their opinion before the next UN climate conference in Ethiopia in November 2027, the first COP in sub-Saharan Africa since the Paris Agreement in 2015.
The advisory opinion is also being closely watched by small Pacific island states. International lawyer Harj Narulla, who advises the Solomon Islands, believes that the failure of COPs to effectively address fossil fuels makes climate disputes between states inevitable. He sees the African Court as having an opportunity to shape these future cases by highlighting key issues for the continent.
Key points
- The African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights will deliver an advisory opinion in 2027 on states' obligations regarding climate change.
- The court's opinion may have implications for climate reparations and could shape future cases on climate disputes between states.
- The issue of colonialism is being raised in the context of climate justice, with some arguing that former colonial powers bear greater responsibility for addressing historical injustices.